purchase office 2003 license cheapest access 2003 cost of adobe cs3 best price roxio toast titanium adobe photoshop cheap software best buy quicken deluxe 2010 buy excel separately buy windows xp professional software purchase windows home server 2011 license buy microsoft office 2013 pro buy outlook 2007 software best price windows xp pro sp3 best price adobe after effects cs4 mac best price rosetta stone software windows 7 ultimate license purchase
windows xp price walmart buy office 2007 standard license used dreamweaver cs3 purchase wordperfect corel best price bento 2 purchase wordperfect office x3 cheap guitar pro 6 buy microsoft word uk cost of 2007 microsoft word dreamweaver cs5 cheap parallels cheapest price buy wordperfect office x4 home student flash catalyst price powerdirector 9 discount buy adobe illustrator cs2 software

Who Said It?: Reveal

QuestionMark-300x2991Spinach is full of pleasant surprises [and a top-ten "power food"].  It’s a natural source of iron… and a rich non-dairy source of calcium.

Those sentences appear in The Sonoma Diet, penned by Registered Dietitian Connie Guttersen.

I find it incomprehensible that a Registered Dietitian can make such an elementary mistake.

Although spinach offers plenty of vitamins, antioxidants, and phytonutrients, it is not a rich source of iron or calcium.

Unlike other leafy greens (i.e.: bok choy, broccoli, mustard greens, and kale) which are very good sources of both those minerals, spinach is loaded with compouds known as oxalates.

Oxalates bind to iron and calcium, significantly decreasing absorption of those minerals in our digestive systems.

Consider the following:

  • A half cup of cooked Chinese cabbage delivers as much calcium as a cup of milk
  • One and a quarter cups of cooked bok choy deliver as much calcium as a cup of milk
  • Eight cups of cooked spinach deliver as much calcium as a cup of milk

What makes this tricky is that the figures presented for spinach in terms of iron and calcium content do not take into account decreased absorption.  Therefore, you will see that a half cup of cooked spinach “provides” 115 milligrams of calcium (11% of the Daily Value).  Sadly, we only absorb 10 to 15% of that amount.

Please share this tidbit with as many people as you can.  I am continually amazed by the amount of health professionals (dietitians, doctors, and educators) who keep this myth alive.

Share

2 Comments

  1. Andy Bellatti said on April 2nd, 2010

    Alicia,

    So glad to hear you are debunking this myth one person at a time! Have a good weekend.

  2. Sarah @ Semi-Sweet said on April 22nd, 2010

    Yes! Even my endocrinologist suggested spinach to me – and when I told her that I’d have to eat a bucket-full to get the same benes as eating bok choy, she was stunned. So much partial/mis-information out there.

Leave a Reply

Trackbacks