cheap windows 7 student edition price of microsoft office 2007 student buy office 2010 student buy windows server 2003 enterprise edition license discount photoshop cs4 mac upgrade best price painter x cheap microsoft office 2008 mac buy anime studio debut 6 uk discount cyberlink powerdirector buy corel videostudio pro best buy microsoft office mac 2011 buy adobe acrobat 9 mac buy 3ds max 2010 adobe photoshop to buy buy server 2008 enterprise sql
  • buy adobe flash cs5 mac buy microsoft office 2013 student and home price of ms office 2013 professional in india how much does guitar pro cost buy lightroom download microsoft publisher 2007 price best buy quicken 2010 adobe acrobat 9 standard best price cheapest version of microsoft office 2010 windows 7 starter price buy photoshop cs3 upgrade best price windows 7 oem best price elements 8 adobe cheap indesign mac purchase outlook express 2010

  • You Ask, I Answer: Fish Oil Supplements/Metal Toxicity Cleansings

    Yesterday I attended a talk given by an “applied clinical nutritionist” who works at a local pharmacy.

    She really advocated the use of supplements for everyone (probably because the pharmacy she works at generates a lot of revenue through the sale of herbs/supplements and homeopathic remedies).

    She recommended taking fish oil instead of flax because she said that flax requires an extra step to be processed by the body.

    She said that some people’s bodies aren’t able to perform this extra step and you would never know one way or another, so she just prefers to stick with fish oil.

    Since you often recommend flax, what are your thoughts?

    She also talked about “cleansing” (the colon in particular).

    Her recommendation wasn’t about losing weight, but rather to flush out toxins, no matter how healthy your diet.

    She said this is needed to flush out “toxins” that accumulate in our bodies from pesticides in food, air pollution, etc.

    The cleanse involves eating certain kinds of foods (she wasn’t specific) and taking some sort of supplements that help flush your colon, like magnesium (I think).

    All of this sounded sort of unnecessary to me.

    Is there any evidence that this type of cleanse is beneficial for people whose diets are already consist of nutritious, whole foods?

    – Kristin (last name withheld)
    Austin, TX

    Before I begin, let me thank Kristin for following up her question with an e-mail revealing the results of her own investigative research.

    Turns out that acquiring the “applied clinical nutritionist” title is a simple task.

    “It’s a self paced certificate program through the Texas Chiropractic College. To earn the certificate, you must be a health care professional, or the staff or student of a health care professional (I suppose you could be a dental receptionist). You have to attend 7 seminars (100 hrs), take a test and pay $1400. In return, you get a shiny wall plaque,” writes Kristin.

    Sigh. Anyhow, onto Kristin’s question.

    As far as the fish vs. flax issue, I agree with the speaker, to a point.

    It is true that the Omega-3 fats found in flaxseed (ALA) need to be converted by the body to DPA and EHA.

    It is also accurate to say that the majority of people do not convert ALA efficiently.

    A significant factor inhibiting conversion is that Omega 6 fatty acids compete with Omega 3 fatty acids for the same desaturase (conversion) enzymes.

    Keeping in mind that our current food supply contributes an abundance of Omega 6, you can see why ALA –> DHA/EPA conversion isn’t happening as optimally as we would expect.

    That being said, I still recommend ground flax simply because most people don’t consume much of ANY Omega-3′s.

    Simply put, ground flaxseeds are an effortless way to add some Omega 3′s to a variety of foods (not everyone likes fish or wants to eat it.)

    I also hope that the speaker’s recommendation of taking fish oil supplements was mainly targeted at people who do not consume fish (or sea vegetables, which offer the same omega-3 fatty acids).

    I would much rather you get your DHA and EPA from actual food first, and consider supplements a “second best” choice.

    Furthermore, I hope she stressed that non-DHA/EPA sources of Omega-3′s offer a wide array of nutrients.

    Ditching walnuts and flaxseed and instead swallowing a spoonful of fish oil every morning isn’t necessarily a smart swap.

    What I COMPLETELY disagree with her on (and why I doubt she is an RD) is her colon cleanse recommendation. It is unnecessary and not particularly healthy. If people want to “flush out” their colons, all they need to do is consume more insoluble fiber and liquids. Plain and simple.

    Not to mention, I would love to ask this expert how, exactly, toxins accumulate in a body with a regularly functioning liver and kidneys. There is no evidence whatsoever supporting the belief that we need to cleanse ourselves of toxins.

    What I find most illogical is that people who furiously support colon cleanses apparently fail to realize that colon cleansing eliminates all the HEALTHY bacteria in the human gut and can cause electrolyte imbalances!

    If you’ll excuse me, I now need to go center myself.

    Share

    4 Comments

    1. Health Guru Girl said on October 14th, 2008

      when i was little, they gave us “Bacalao” oil in small gel pills. This was supposed to be great for our brain. So all this information actually proves my mother’s point. Thank for the article.

    2. Cat said on October 15th, 2008

      Very enlightening, thanks! One of my friends have tried to talk me into the benefits of “cleanses” and “cleansing fasts”. I feel that I eat a great, balanced diet 99.9% of the time, exercise, keep my mind healthy, etc. and therefore have no huge accumulation of toxins in my body.

      I feel like people often get swept up in nutrition fads… especially ones that involve big, drastic steps. Why people don’t get that just maintaining a healthy lifestyle in a relaxed, sustainable way is the way to go is sooo beyond me!

    3. Andy Bellatti said on October 15th, 2008

      Cat, I think it’s because maintaining a healthy lifestyle entails a long-standing commitment.

      The cleanse, on the other hand, is only a week long… and it cures all your ailments! (insert eyeroll HERE)

      At this point, I’m expecting the next trendy cleanse to also make your bed and ask you how your day was when you get home.

    4. Supplements said on October 23rd, 2008

      Find your site in google, and it has a lot of useful information. Thanks

    Leave a Reply

    Trackbacks